Rare Beauty Bet on a Stranger and Built a $2.5 Billion Brand
Five of the top ten beauty brands are now celebrity-founded. The ones that pick a story first are pulling ahead of the ones that share the same face across six competitors.
In July 2026, Rare Beauty named its first celebrity ambassador: Ella Bright, the lead of Amazon's Off Campus, a streaming show that drew 36 million viewers in its first two weeks. She was not famous for beauty. The campaign was produced in under a month. Rare Beauty is valued at approximately $2.5 billion.
That same year, Hailey Bieber was fronting multiple competing brands simultaneously, generating between $3.8 million and $7.2 million in Media Impact Value for each partnership, according to Launchmetrics data cited in a November 11 FashionUnited UK analysis. The numbers are real. The question the analysis asks is what happens to brand identity when the same face is shared across six or seven competitors.
One Face, Many Logos
Launchmetrics CMO Alison Bringé described the direction brands should be moving toward: treating talent "less as a campaign asset and more as a long-term storytelling partner." The test, by that standard, is whether a campaign survives when you remove the logo. For a face that appeared simultaneously on DKNY, Mango, Skims, Gap, and Adanola in the same period, the logo is doing more of the work each time.
Our own search tracking measured the gap. Search interest for "rare beauty" peaked at 100 on October 28, 2026, and held at 32 on November 14, sustained by Selena Gomez and Demi Lovato's friendship campaign in late October. Search interest for "hailey bieber brand" peaked at 1 on November 8 and had faded before the week ended. The gap reflects which model consumers return to outside of a campaign window.
MAC's Different Bet
MAC saw the same logic and committed to it. When the brand named Chappell Roan its global ambassador in December 2025, creative director Nicola Formichetti described her as "the perfect Viva Glam girl," framing the partnership as alignment rather than rental. The 2026 Viva Glam collection launched June 11 with a co-created limited-edition lip line, with 100 percent of proceeds going to organizations supporting gender, racial, and environmental equality. MAC did not pay for Roan's reach. It aligned its existing values with someone who embodied them.
What Failure Looks Like
The failures are equally instructive. Gwen Stefani's GXVE Beauty shut down in early 2026. Drew Barrymore's Flower Beauty ceased operations in September 2025. Neither lacked celebrity recognition. Both lacked a durable story beneath the name. A Fortune analysis from October 2026 noted that fame alone is not enough and that trust drives repeat purchases. Five of the top 10 beauty brands by creator marketing performance are celebrity-founded, according to the Traackr Creator Advantage 2026 report.
The scale of the market makes the distinction matter more, not less. TikTok Shop is now the fourth-largest U.S. health and beauty e-commerce retailer, with sales above $4.4 billion, according to NielsenIQ figures cited in Fortune. Creator volume in beauty rose 66 percent year over year, while average audience size fell 30 percent. The old math of celebrity reach, one face broadcast to millions, is giving way to something more specific: smaller audiences, deeper trust, and a clearer answer to the question of why this person and not someone else.
Rhode's $1 Billion Counterargument
Rhode's sale to e.l.f. for up to $1 billion in 2025 is the strongest argument for the other model. Bieber built a brand, found an acquirer, and kept doing endorsement work after the sale. The $1 billion is real. It went to e.l.f., though, not to Rhode's customers, and Rhode now builds meaning inside a larger portfolio. That is a successful exit. Rare Beauty, by contrast, holds an estimated $2.5 billion valuation while still founder-controlled and without a comparable headline exit.
The two models are not equally durable by the data. The shared-face approach generates predictable MIV in the short term. The story-first approach builds the kind of loyalty that shows up in search interest six months after a campaign ends. Rare Beauty's October peak was driven by a collaboration, not a paid ad, and held for weeks. Glossy described the brand's approach as "story-first," produced in under a month, and chosen for cultural fit rather than follower count. That is what compounding brand value looks like from the data side.
MAC's Viva Glam Chappell Roan collection launched on June 11, 2026, and sales figures have not been disclosed as of November. Rare Beauty's Ella Bright campaign is ongoing. e.l.f.'s integration of Rhode brand is expected to yield public announcements around early 2027, though no date has been set. The signal to watch is whether Bieber's remaining brand partnerships generate sustained search interest after each campaign window closes, or whether the shared-face model fades as fast as it spikes.
Sources & further reading
- FashionUnited UK (Sara Ehlers): When every brand wants the same face, who stands out? Nov 11 2026
- Fortune (Fernanda Tronco): Kylie Jenner, Selena Gomez, and Hailey Bieber's brands dominate beauty creator economy. Oct 1 2026
- Glossy (Emily Jensen): Why Rare Beauty is taking a story-first approach to celebrity ambassadors. Jul 17 2026
- Global Cosmetics News: MAC appoints Chappell Roan Global Brand Ambassador. Dec 10 2025
- Wikimedia Commons: Chappell Roan performing in Paris, Aug 20 2025 (Raph_PH, CC BY 4.0)
- Wikimedia Commons: Hailey Bieber at WWD Style Awards 2026 (Kevin Paul / WikiPortraits, CC BY 4.0)




