The Backlash Reformation Put Olivia Jade in 'College.' Nobody's Apologizing. Follow the Money Shaq Turned Down $5M Because 'I Can't Tell People It's From My Sweat' The Backlash Sweeney Tagged 'Disgusting' for Cindy Lou Who. Those Were Pajamas. Say What? Trisha Yearwood Shows Up 30 Lbs Down at NYC Gala, No Garth in Sight Say What? Goodman Hit 400 Lbs After Going Sober: 'I Was Eating Alcoholically' Celebrity Gossip Alex Cooper Delivers: 'The Most Transformative 9 Months of My Life' Brand Strategy Sweeney Channels Cindy Lou Who and Sally to Launch SYRN's Holiday Shop Say What? Donnie Wahlberg's Jet Skids Off Vegas Runway: "God Covered Us" The Backlash Reformation Put Olivia Jade in 'College.' Nobody's Apologizing. Follow the Money Shaq Turned Down $5M Because 'I Can't Tell People It's From My Sweat' The Backlash Sweeney Tagged 'Disgusting' for Cindy Lou Who. Those Were Pajamas. Say What? Trisha Yearwood Shows Up 30 Lbs Down at NYC Gala, No Garth in Sight Say What? Goodman Hit 400 Lbs After Going Sober: 'I Was Eating Alcoholically' Celebrity Gossip Alex Cooper Delivers: 'The Most Transformative 9 Months of My Life' Brand Strategy Sweeney Channels Cindy Lou Who and Sally to Launch SYRN's Holiday Shop Say What? Donnie Wahlberg's Jet Skids Off Vegas Runway: "God Covered Us"
Ad Watch News
The Backlash

Sweeney Tagged 'Disgusting' for Cindy Lou Who. Those Were Pajamas.

SYRN's holiday campaign puts Sweeney in a plaid nightgown and fur-lined cape for the Cindy Lou Who scene. The commenters calling it 'disgusting' are reacting to the brand, not what is actually in the frame.

Go Where No Reader Has Gone Before ↓
Sydney Sweeney at the Berlinale 2023 photo call, amber thermal treatment on ink-speckle field. Ad Watch News composition.
Elena Ternovaja / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

Sydney Sweeney posted her SYRN holiday campaign on October 21 and the comments filled fast with one word: disgusting. The target was a scene where she wears a plaid nightgown, a fur-lined cape, and a curled-up hairstyle referencing Cindy Lou Who from "How the Grinch Stole Christmas." One commenter wrote: "Making a child character sexual isn't it." Another asked: "Why is she posing as child characters in a lingerie ad?" A third called for the creative director to be fired.

Worth pausing on what is actually in the Cindy Lou sequence.

Fashion coverage of the campaign describes the look as cozy plaid pajamas. She carries presents. She plays with Christmas lights beside a tree. The nightgown and cape stay on through those shots. The lingerie comes later: a black lace bodysuit in one sequence, a red bow bra with a garter belt in another, and an ice-blue lace set that closes the Romantic section of the campaign. Those shots are not styled as Cindy Lou Who.

The Critics Are Reacting to the Brand, Not the Content

The backlash pattern is now legible: anything Sweeney does inside a lingerie brand context reads as sexual to a certain group of commenters, regardless of what the actual frame shows. The word "disgusting" implies that specific content crosses a line. No one citing that word has identified a shot where Cindy Lou Who appears in lingerie, because there is not one in the campaign.

The more precise critique against this kind of campaign is that a lingerie brand borrowing children's IP creates an uneasy context even when the character's own scenes are tame. That is a real creative argument. The borrowed charm of a beloved child character is being used to sell a brand that trades on adult content, and the warmth of the childhood association does not fully separate from the brand's identity. That case is at least coherent.

It is not the case most commenters were making. They said "disgusting." "Disgusting" names the content. The content was pajamas.

Four Collections, Shop Opens October 27

The campaign covers four holiday capsule lines. The Comfy drop references Kevin McCallister from "Home Alone": Sweeney in a cream knit sweater, eating ice cream from an oversized bowl in a leather armchair. The Playful and Romantic capsules contain the lingerie pieces. The Romantic sequence, which features the red bow bra set and a sheer satin veil, frames her as a wrapped gift under a circular spotlight.

SYRN's holiday shop opens October 27. Neither Sweeney nor the brand had commented publicly on the backlash at publication time.

SYRN has now drawn scrutiny from the American Eagle campaign, the Novig sports betting ad, and a Cindy Lou Who pajama scene. The brand's controversy cycle is compressing. Whether that is a bug or a feature is the question no one at SYRN has answered in public.

AdvertisementGeneral Tire advertisementDune Awakening advertisement

Sources & further reading

More news
Independent commentary. Ad Watch News is an independent commentary and news publication. It is not affiliated with, authorized by, endorsed by, or sponsored by any celebrity, brand, or company mentioned. All trademarks belong to their respective owners. Coverage is editorial opinion and reporting on matters of public interest. See our editorial standards.